This Emmy and Grammy nominated comedian was not joking around when she belted out “Time After Time” by Cyndi Lauper, leaving the judges completely confused about her identity. Nicole Scherzinger’s final guess: Terry Bradshaw Jenny McCarthy’s final guess: Peyton Manning Robin Thicke’s final guess: Terry Bradshaw Despite being known for his prowess on the playing field and not his voice, Bradshaw only fooled half of the judging panel. This NFL Hall of Famer won four Super Bowl titles as the quarterback of the Pittsburgh Steelers, but it was when he suited up as the Deer and serenaded viewers with “Get Your Shine On” by Florida Georgia Line that he revealed his hidden singing talent. Nicole Scherzinger’s final guess: Kid Rock Jenny McCarthy’s final guess: Cheech Marin

Robin Thicke’s final guess: Sugar Ray Lenoard Chong left all four judges up in smoke, although Jenny came close by guessing his frequent co-star, Cheech Marin. This comedic legend said he’s willing to do “anything to get on stage,” and dressing up in a costume while singing “I Will Survive” by Gloria Gaynor was not beneath him. Nicole Scherzinger’s final guess: Allen Iverson Jenny McCarthy’s final guess: Deion Sanders Robin Thicke’s final guess: Odell Beckham Jr. Brown stumped all four judges after his wacky performance of “My Prerogative” by Bobby Brown. This NFL player entered “Masked Singer” history when he became the first costumed celebrity to be unmasked in front of America.

Another Life by Owen W. Knight